Important announcement

Dear visitor,

Please note that this OpenCourseWare platform will be replaced at the end of 2026 by a new platform (under the same url ocw.tudelft.nl).

Courses and their contents that are currently available the platform will partly be migrated. URL’s for this content will change and content might be unavailable for some time. In addition, some courses will not be available anymore.

If you are linking to specific courses on this platform (for instance for your students), please take timely measures to avoid problems with access. Possible actions are:

  • Download the materials to your local platform (laptop, server)
  • For educators only (including TU Delft lecturers): Contact us at ocw@tudelft.nl and inform us what course you are using in what context (institute, program, period of use, number of students). We will research (in collaboration with the authors of the course) and decide if we will migrate the course, and if yes, can supply you with a new url.

Thank you.

2.1.1 Whose assessments are more valuable?

Course subject(s) Module 2. Calibration and Information score

“Watermelons” by Ahmad is licensed under CC BY-NC 2.0

What is the percentage of water in watermelon?

To answer this question, we consult two experts (expert A & expert B).  Each expert gives their 5%, 50% and 95% quantiles which can be seen in the table below.

Expert 5% 50% 95%
Expert A 80 90 94
Expert B 93 95 97

Recall that, with their assessments, the experts are sending the following message:

Expert A:
– the median (50% quantile) estimate is 90, so (s)he believes that 90% is the best estimate for the percent of water in the watermelon. (S)he believes there is a 50% chance that the true water percentage  is below or above 90.
– the lower bound (5% quantile) is 80, the is, (s)he believes there is a 5% chance that the true water percentage is below 80%.
– the upper bound (95%) is 94 the is, (s)he believes there is a 5% chance that the true water percentage is above 94%.

Concluding, according to expert A assessments, her/his best estimate is 90% and her/his uncertainty is given by the credible interval (80%,94%), that is, (s)he believes there is 90% chance that the true water percentage is between 80% and 94%.

Expert B:
– the median (50% quantile) estimate is 95, so (s)he believes that 95% is the best estimate for the percent of water in the watermelon. (S)he believes there is a 50% chance that the true water percentage  is below or above 95.
– the lower bound (5% quantile) is 93, the is, (s)he believes there is a 5% chance that the true water percentage is below 93%.
– the upper bound (95%) is 97 the is, (s)he believes there is a 5% chance that the true water percentage is above 97%.

Concluding, according to expert B assessments, her/his best estimate is 95% and her/his uncertainty is given by the credible interval (93%,97%), that is, (s)he believes there is 90% chance that the true water percentage is between 93% and 97%.

What is the percentage of water in watermelon? We now know that the true value is 92%!

Creative Commons License
Decision Making Under Uncertainty: Introduction to Structured Expert Judgment by TU Delft OpenCourseWare is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Based on a work at https://online-learning.tudelft.nl/courses/decision-making-under-uncertainty-introduction-to-structured-expert-judgment//.
Back to top
[sg_popup id=6]